From the New England Journal of Medicine, a recent physician survey on the effects of the pending health care reform legislation on physician supply:
Physician Support of Health Reform in General
â€¢ 62.7% of physicians feel that health reform is needed but should be implemented in a more targeted, gradual way, as opposed to the sweeping overhaul that is in legislation.
â€¢ 28.7% of physicians are in favor of a public option.
â€¢ 3.6% of physicians prefer the â€œstatus quoâ€ and feel that the U.S. health care system is best â€œas is.
Health Reform and Primary Care Physicians
â€¢ 46.3% of primary care physicians (family medicine and internal medicine) feel that the passing of health reform will either force them out of medicine or make them want to leave medicine.
Health Reform, Public Option, and Practice Revenue/Physician Income
â€¢ 41% of physicians feel that income and practice revenue will â€œdecline or worsen dramaticallyâ€ with a public option.
â€¢ 30% feel income will â€œdecline or worsen somewhatâ€ with a public option.
â€¢ 9% feel income will â€œimprove somewhatâ€ with a public option, and 0.8% feel income will â€œimprove dramaticallyâ€ with a public option.
Health Reform, Public Option, and Physician Supply
â€¢ 72% of physicians feel that a public option would have a negative impact on physician supply, with 45% feeling it will â€œdecline or worsen dramaticallyâ€ and 27% predicting it will â€œdecline or worsen somewhat.
â€¢ 24% of physicians think they will try to retire early if a public option is implemented.
â€¢ 21% of physicians would try to leave medicine if a public option is implemented, even if not near retirement age at the time.
Health Reform and Recommending Medicine to Others as a Career
â€¢ 36% of physicians would not recommend medicine as a career, regardless of health reform.
â€¢ 27% would recommend medicine as a career but not if health reform passes.
â€¢ 25% of physicians would recommend medicine as a career regardless of health reform.
â€¢ 12% would not recommend medicine as a career now but feel that they would recommend it as a career if health reform passes
And this from the New York Times today:
With states squeezing payments to providers even as the economy fuels explosive growth in enrollment, patients are finding it increasingly difficult to locate doctors and dentists who will accept their coverage. Inevitably, many defer care or wind up in hospital emergency rooms, which are required to take anyone in an urgent condition.
The inadequacy of Medicaid payments is severe enough that it has become a rare point of agreement in the health care debate between President Obama and Congressional Republicans. In a letter to Congress after their February health care meeting, Mr. Obama wrote that rates might need to rise [hedge alert!] if Democrats achieved their goal of extending Medicaid eligibility to 15 million uninsured Americans.
In 2008, Medicaid reimbursements averaged only 72 percent of the rates paid by Medicare, which are themselves typically well below those of commercial insurers, according to the Urban Institute, a research group. At 63 percent, Michigan had the sixth-lowest rate in the country, even before the recent cuts.
In Flint, Dr. Nita M. Kulkarni, an obstetrician, receives $29.42 from Medicaid for a visit that would bill $69.63 from Blue Cross Blue Shield of Michigan. She receives $842.16 from Medicaid for a Caesarean delivery, compared with $1,393.31 from Blue Cross.
What the Times neglects to mention is that physicians’ overhead expenses substantially exceed these reimbursements — every Medicaid patient seen will cost the physician more than they will be reimbursed, often substantially more. Malpractice premiums annually for obstetricians? Generally well over $100,000. It takes a lot of $29 office visits to pay for that — and that’s just one part of overhead.
So, for those who believe we have to do “something” to fix health care, so let’s just pass this monstrosity and fix it later, this is what you’re looking at: fewer doctors, already in significant shortage; health “insurance” that pays so poorly no physician will be financially able to see you.
My suggestions, if this health care bill passes? 1) stay healthy, very healthy; 2) start saving a lot of money, since your only access to health care will likely be a shadow system where physicians will see you for cash only.
Welcome to the new millennium in health care.
What’s the alternative? Well, I hope to lay some out in the near future, time permitting.