
If you have a serious case of insomnia, have far too much time on your hands — or have a vested interest in not seeing government take over your health care — then you will want to spend quality time reading the legislation which will change your life, irrevocably and disastrously, forever: HR 3200, “America’s Affordable Health Choices Act of 2009″. Various summaries and commentaries are floating about the web, and while helpful, they are tainted by too much histrionic commentary, often SHOUTED TO MAKE A POINT! which may or may not be be a valid inference from the legislation.
Here’s the HTML version with links.
So now you can go straight to the source, and judge for yourselves. Even though your elected representatives will try to pass this without reading it, that doesn’t mean you can’t do the responsible thing and get informed.
Here’s a good summary of HR 3200’s key aspects, from AAPS:
New bureaucracies: These include State Health Help Agencies (HHAs), with a federal fallback plan should states refuse to create them; an advisory committee to report annually on modifications of benefits, etc.; some mechanism to “adjust” the Medicare Part B premium based on whether or not each individual “participates in certain healthy behaviors”; other agencies to calculate payments, monitor individual behavior, set standards as for chronic disease management, check compliance with standards, monitor loss ratios and outcomes of chronic-care management, etc.
Individual mandate. All adults must buy a government-approved Healthy Americans Private Insurance Plan (HAPI) [love the abbreviation!] and constantly report on compliance, at every interaction with federal, state, and local government, including at voter registration, motor vehicle departments, or other checkpoints, as well as when filing tax forms. This applies to all legal residents, including non-citizens, although not to illegal aliens.
Penalties. The penalty includes the average monthly premium, plus 15%, for all “uncovered” months. Penalties are not subject to discharge by bankruptcy. This means that the HHA, which receives the penalties, takes precedence over other creditors.
Insurance mandates. Guaranteed issue, community rating, coverage of “wellness” without copayments, annual physicals, a required “health home” (gatekeeper), mental health parity, and reconstructive surgery post mastectomy are all mandatory. Each HAPI plan “shall” make available supplemental coverage for abortion, unless affiliated with a religious institution.
Progressive taxation equivalent. Premium subsidies are phased out incrementally up to 400% of poverty. This means that working harder and earning more is punished by higher mandated health insurance “premiums” (which are the functional equivalent of taxes). People will constantly be reporting on their income status.
School-based clinics. Care must be provided at no cost, or on a reimbursable basis, by school-based clinics, which must provide, “at a minimum,” mental health services, and use electronic medical records by 2012.
Job killer. Every employer “shall pay an employer shared responsibility payment,” which increases for each additional employee in excess of 50. Employers must deduct the individual shared responsibility payment from wages “as and when paid.” This amount is not allowed as a deduction from the employer’s taxable income.
Savings. To offset the costs, Medicare and 90% of Medicaid disproportionate share (DSH) payments are to be “recaptured.” Tax exclusions for health benefits will be limited (sections 661-666). According to section 801, “private insurance companies will be forced to hold down costs and will slow the rate of growth because they are required to offer standardized Healthy Americans Private Insurance plans.”
These cool cats in Congress are, of course, only interested in your welfare, and always have the interest of their constituents first and foremost in their minds:

So give them a piece of your mind, here.
The hour is late, and the corrupt political class wants to radically transform the health care system — not for your benefit, but for theirs.
Get to work before its too late.
7 comments so far ↓
Joe // Aug 6, 2009 at 9:34 am
This is a very good synopsis of the issues with the health care bill.
When I have tried to generalize, however, many have commented on my sight that I am just fear-mongering, or that it really does not provide for what I have indicated.
Therefore, I have listed the issues and the location in the bill in which they are found.
I have expressed my opinions to my legislators and will continue to do so…even at their “town meetings.”
Marilyn // Aug 9, 2009 at 4:28 pm
I have linked to your post on my blog. Not that my blog gets a lot of traffic!
I appreciate your treatment of the bill and hope a few more people will stop by here. I stumbled here from the Biblical Christianity blog.
ablur // Aug 10, 2009 at 3:20 pm
I too have spent a lot of time on the Healthcare bill. I see it as using an atomic bomb to solve a problem that could use a sniper.
I have carefully laid out the key issues that need resolution in order to fix/reduce the cost of healthcare. Nobody seems to want to deal with the real problems.
Thank you for your candor in explaining the travesty known as the Healthcare Bill.
dracul, MD // Aug 15, 2009 at 6:58 am
Explain what are the benefits of the politicos re: this bill. Besides campaign funding, you need to clarify. The basic problem is NOT the health care bill itself, but the legality of lobbying and the financing of our representation by interest groups.
Health insurance industry and pharm industry are the predators here. I am not sure you can take the words of physicians, including myself, on this, as we have a vested interest in the status quo.
CharleyWhiskey // Aug 17, 2009 at 6:37 pm
OK, the present system is dysfunctional and the proposed system is an Obomination. It is easy to find fault with both. What then is good plan? How exactly should it work? I see plenty of statements about what a good plan should include or avoid, but I don’t see an actual alternative plan.
On ‘Death Panels’, Compassion & Choice | The Doctor Is In // Aug 18, 2009 at 5:20 pm
[…] RSS When you understand what you see, you will no longer be children. You will know that life is pain, that each of us hangs always upon the cross of himself. And when you know that this is true of every man, woman and child on earth, you will be wiser. -Whittaker Chambers- ← H.R. 3200 […]
Kendallini // Aug 21, 2009 at 4:59 am
great blog….
Joe, Can you please provide the bill links or page cites. My favorite is the healthy lifestyle considerations…and school nurse requirements……sounds a lot like what insurance companies do with pre-existing conditions.
WelfAre reform was intended to help single parent families after vietnam… It was predicted it would destroy poor African American families and by most accounts IT DID JUST THAT. The Mass. gay marriage law was intended to support gay families without impacting heterosexuals… yet the martial parity provisions forced Catholic Charities to cease its adoption program bc of the tax impact caused by not treating gay and heterosexual couples “the same” when it came to adoption of Catholic babies. Mass. has other adoption agencies which are available to gay couples so this was not the only route to adoption. What unintended consequence will this bill have.
Leave a Comment